|
FoxexAutoPilot
Review
FAP
FAPTS EA
ExpertAdvisor Trading
Robots
|
Print This Page
|
|
|
|

|
|
Price: US $99.00
|
Overview
ForexAutoPilot
(FAPS) is probably the most
popular Metatrader automated trading system out there.
(Please be aware there is another web site selling
completely different software with a very similar name -
Forex-Autopilot-Systems.com by Mark Copeland).
Like all of the robot systems,
it runs on Metatrader 4 (MT4).
Marketing Claims
Like many of the over-hyped Expert
Advisors (EAs) around, FAPS has its fair share of outlandish
claims.
"According
to history backtests from 1999-2008 and live trading
results, the FAP EA makes 96% winning trades ".
“Since its
inception 18-months ago FAPS has been responsible for the
creation of 8 millionaires with an additional 3,000 clients
reporting earnings in excess of $100,000 per
year.”
Cost
Forex Auto Pilot System
(FAPS) costs $399.50 US, but everyone is offered a
75% discount which brings the cost down to around $99
US.
The Package
-
The Forex Autopilot
Robot
According to the manual, the trading system used by
Forex Autopilot is based on more than 20 well-known
forex indicators such as Alligator, Fractals,
DeMarker, William’s Percent Rate, etc. Based
on what I’ve seen so far, the system always uses a
20 pip Take Profit limit, but does not implement a
stop loss strategy and depends on its own internal
signals to close losing trades.
-
The Bonus Non-Farm-Payroll
Robot
The monthly announcement of NFP figures in the US
is one of the most volatile moments in the Forex
market, and you can make hundreds of pips within 1
hour if you trade it correctly. An Expert
Advisor is great for this because it can make
decisions in an instant, which is exactly what you
need in order to profit from NFPs.
-
The Bonus Ultra Trend
Indicator
The Ultra Trend indicator is a combination of
indicators that seems to be very accurate in
finding the direction and strength of the trend, as
well as key support and resistance levels. It
comes with a detailed instruction manual and sample
setups that you can use to start trading.
-
Documentation
WIth the Forex Autopilot package you receive
detailed documentation for each of the above 3
systems, as well as a 74 page advanced Forex
trading guide for those who wish to learn more
about things like Scalping, Martingale, Money
Management and many others which is worth reading.
Related Products
There are 2 related products to
FAPS:
FAP Winner provides additional support
and other related services for FAPS and FAP Turbo. For more
info on FAP Winner read the section on Support.
FAP Turbo is an extension of FAPS that
includes a scalper for some of the crosses.
Refund Policy
As the system is sold through
clickbank, it automatically comes with a 60 day refund
policy.
Who Wrote FAPS?
|

|
|
Marcus Leary
|
According to the FAPS web page the
system was developed by “A Highly Ranked Industry Insider
and a Mathematician”. If you read further, the FAPS
web goes on to say that Marcus Alexander Leary developed
FAPS along with his programmer buddy with an “unbelievable
head for figures”, Steven Strauss. We presume Marcus is the
“Highly Ranked Industry Insider” and Steven is the
“Mathematician”.
Support
FAPS comes with email based support. I
have tried using it and they do respond eventually, but I
found that they didn’t really answer my questions. The
standard response seemed to be to point you to the
introductory videos, which don’t answer my questions either.
If you persist you can get an answer via email.
|

|
|
Charles A Foyd
II
|
|
|
Where there are problems, there exists
opportunity. In order to improve the support, in April 2008
a FAPS user, Charles A Floyd II, created a FAP User Group Yahoo Forum to
provide free support to other FAPS users. Since the forum's
inception. Charles has also set up a commercial FAPS support
service called FAP Winner, which promotes a
modified version of the FAPS EA called the Forex
AutoPilotTradingSystem (FAPTS). Charles and Marcus both
respond to questions on the free Yahoo forum, but they are
now increasingly pushing participants to the commercial FAP
Winner service.
According to the FAP Winner site, Charles is a full time
forex trader with over 20 years of experience trading a
range of markets. Apparently, he also manages assets for
Marcus and for a small number of other clients as well.
FAP Winner comes with two levels of
membership: Monthly - US$99 up front + US$49 per month and
Supreme - US$599 for 12 month membership. The main
difference between the levels is access to better, more
timely support, additional mentoring and access to
additional non-FAPS EAs. I did sign up for the silver level
of membership before it went to the monthly fee. For the
silver level or monthly membership you receive:
-
FAPTS EA
This is FAP preloaded with the FAPTS Optimized
settings, so all you have to do is adjust your lot
size. Unlike FAP, Charles recommends trading with
the trend so in a down you take only short trades
and vice versa for an uptrend.
-
Trading Plan
This is a
calculator that shows you how to calculate lot
sizes depending on your account balance, and how
many successful trades are required for you to make
a million dollars (the plan makes the rather poor
assumption that 100% of your trades will be
successful).
-
Online
Forum
Chares publishes his weekly trading setting for
FAPTS on the forum. The forum also covers a wide
range of topics relating to FAPTS and FapTurbo as
well as reviews of other EAs. The FapTurbo
developers seems participate more in the FapWinner
forum than the free FapTurbo forum.
-
Support Line
Access to a
support line (a web form which sends an email)
-
Documentation
A PDF document
describing how to set up and trade FAPTS
-
Trading as a
Business
A 3 page PDF document, by Joe Broadhurst, which
talks about “trading as a business”
I have tried the FAP Winner support
line for a few questions and I found the team to be prompt
with their responses. However, on both the FAP Winner forum
and the Yahoo forum, you are expected to follow Charles’s
lead. Exploration of alternative ways of how FAPS might be
used or open critical thinking about Charles’ methods is
pretty heavily moderated, and outright dissension is not
tolerated.
If you are interested in free
"non-Marcus / non-Charles affiliated" support for FAPS
products you can also go to another forexautopilotforum . This
group explores a much wider range of ideas about how FAPS
could be used and moderation is not nearly as heavy handed.
What I really like about this group is they have an ongoing
back-testing competition to find the best settings to get
the most out of FAPS and FAP Turbo.
How They Work
Like all the EAs that I have reviewed
so far, FAPS and FAPTS are “grey box” systems, meaning that
the internal logic of how it trades is proprietary, but the
user can adjust some of the settings. If you read their
documentation, there is little clue as to how it works, but
Marcus’s responses to questions provides more insight.
Markets
According to
Marcus, FAPS is really only useful for trading the EUR/USD
on the 1 minute chart: Having said that, you can
still trade FAPS on any market that your MetaTrader 4 broker
supports. Some forum members report that FAPS has been
traded effectively on GBP/USD, USD/JPY and the USD/CHF.
The ForexAutoPilotForum community have
found that you can also successfully trade FAPS on a 5
minute chart. In back test, the performance of FAPS actually
improves as the entries on a 5 minute chart are better
quality. However, if you increase the time frame again,
performance seems to degrade as you are sacrificing a larger
number of entry opportunities for a further minor
improvement in entry quality.
Entries
When asked about entries for FAPS,
Marcus’s response is that:
“The Trading system of the
ForexAutoPilot expert advisor is based on several modern
Forex indicators such as Alligator, Fractals, DeMarker,
and William’s Percent Rate. The system detects a good
trend and confirms it using internal indicators, then
opens the trades to make maximum profit for you. “
As described above, the systems is
pretty much an intraday trend trading system that is
designed to trade a one minute chart. The entry as far as I
can tell is pretty much what Marcus describes:
-
Enter Long if the Alligator indicator shows a
trending market (default of a 13, 8,5 set of
three smoothed exponential moving averages),
the Williams %R is
not showing an overbought or oversold market,
the Fractal
Indicator is lower and the
Demarker indicator was
recently high.
-
Enter Short if the Alligator indicator shows a
trending market, The Williams %R is not showing an
overbought or oversold market, the Fractal
indicator is higher and the Demarker indicator was
recently low
If you sign up for FAPTS from FAP Winner, they make a number
of further refinements on the entry:
-
FAPTS is set up by default to only trade the London
session between 7 am to 12 pm
-
At the start of each week, Charles will indicate
the major trend on the market (based on weekly /
daily charts) and will ask you to set up FAPTS to
trade in the direction of the market. Charles seems
to use some technical analysis for this.
-
FAPTS uses a “one and then done” philosophy and it
comes with an additional feature to ensure only one
trade is made in a 24 hour period.
Probably the main difference between
FAPS and FAPTS is FAPTS will take far fewer trades than
FAPS, but trading tends to be more consistent because the
trades are opened during a volatile session on the market
(the London open) and the trades are made in the direction
of the dominant trend. Charles
publishes his results on the Fap Winner website.
Exits
When asked
about exits in FAPS, Marcus’s response is that:
“The system does not use a fixed
stop loss parameter to prevent losing trades.
ForexAutoPilot advisor monitors each open trade
carefully and closes it if it reaches the takeprofit
limit when the trade is successful. This “no fixed stop
loss” approach showed great results in numerous
backtesting and straightforward live tests. FAPS makes
96% winning trades.”
Out of the box, the default for FAPS
pretty much does what Marcus says. It comes with a default
20 pip profit target and no stop loss set. The default for
FAPTS is similar except they also use 500 pip stop loss and
a 15 pip trailing stop. On the FAP User Group forums,
sometimes it is suggested that you use a tighter 300 pip
stop loss.
FAPS trades with an internal stop loss
and therefore the stop loss is not entered at the time of
order entry. Marcus’s reason for this is he believes that if
the stop loss is placed as part of the order the broker is
more likely to hunt his stops. So you need the stomach for
large drawdowns.
Marcus also indicates that the system
has an additional stop built into the system where all
negative positions are closed at the end of the month.
According the the FAPTS FAQ, the reason why the EA is
designed to close bad trades at month-end is that:
-
Traders are able to take a fresh start going into
the new month and thus prevents traders from
holding on unnecessarily to losing trades
-
Their tests have shown that once the draw-down has
been exited, the loss taken at month- end close can
be gained back within 2-6 days of the new month.
There are apparently 2 other stops that
FAPS supports based on its own internal indicators.
According to posts I have seen on a couple of different
forums these stops include a “disaster stop” which is
triggered on a sudden spike of a 100 pips or more and a
“whipsaw stop” which is triggered if the price immediately
moves against the entry position. These stops are triggered
very rarely, so you cannot rely on them to protect your
account.
Position Sizing
The FAPS material does not give you any
advice for position sizing. FAPS does have an auto-lot
feature which will calculate the position size based on the
size of the account. How this works is not explained, but it
seems to be a function of the maximum number of orders, lot
sizes and the lots risk reductor.
On the FAP Winner site, there is a
trading plan which is much clearer in terms of lot size
calculation. It simply presumes 1 mini lot per $1000 in the
account (or 0.1 standard lot per $1000 in the account).
Therefore for the same $5000 account, 5 mini lots would be
traded. .
Performance
If you read the FAPS website, you see a
number of claims around performance such as:
-
A back test result which over a 5 year period which
traded $1000 up to $46,638 using a fixed lot size
of 0.1 lots. In this test we see 91% of trades are
profitable and there is a maximum drawdown of
13.47%.
-
A forward test result with real money where $2,910
was traded up to $8,916 using 1 mini lot over a
period of 2 months. In this test we see that 92% of
trades were profitable and the maximum drawdown was
1.41%
I have been not been able to reproduce
the back test result myself. My attempt resulted in the
account blowing up after 25 trades.
Click on the link for
the live results on
FAPS with FXDD.
Weaknesses in the FAPS System
In reflecting on the performance of
FAPS, it achieves its results because it has tight profit
targets (20 pip target) and no stop loss. Over a 4 year
period, it is not surprising that we are seeing a 95+%
success rate, because the EUR/USD is 96% likely to revisit
an earlier price level in that time frame. However, in some
market situations where the market has a massive retracement
and your pockets are not deep enough to handle the drawdown,
there is a risk of loosing a reasonably large chunk of your
account if you are using 300 to 500 pip stops, or nearly all
of your account if your are using no stops at all.
In terms of other potential weaknesses
in this system, there are weaknesses in the trend trading
nature of this system. FAPS is highly likely to go through
periods of extended drawdown in a ranging market. This is
because the FAPS system probably has no filter built into it
to avoid congested ranging markets.
How Best to Trade the Collection of
Systems
At its heart
FAPS is a trend trading system with tight profit targets and
either wide or no stops. The width of the stops means that,
despite the high win rate, there is a chance that the market
may turn against an open trade at any time and leave your
account in tatters. This makes the system a high risk
system. If you are unwilling to tolerate such a risk in your
trading, then this system is not for you.
If you do decide to trade this system,
make sure your demo trade it for a while so that you get a
handle on how it behaves in different market conditions. In
trading it there are a few things you should consider and,
in particular, I think the FAP Winner guidelines for trading
FAPTS are on the money (first dot point below).
-
Generally you should trade FAPS with the dominant
trend. If you see the daily chart approaching a
major trend line or a S/R line and the price action
starts to congest, consider standing aside as the
market may change direction. If you are holding
open positions and the trend definitely ends and
changes direction, you should either consider
closing your open trades and wearing the loss,
putting a stop on your open trades or hedging open
trades. If you are uncomfortable doing this kind of
analysis yourself, you should consider signing up
to FAP Winner as they provide this kind of
information on a weekly basis
-
Follow the Forexautopilotforum discussions, as they
have an ongoing back testing competition and they
are continuously identifying the best settings to
use
-
Consider withdrawing a portion of your profits
regularly. That way if your account does suffer a
major loss you may still have something to show for
it.
Conclusion
It is
obviously your choice as to whether you trade FAPS or
FAPTS.
I am trading
FAPTS live and I intend to continue to do so as long as
the results continue to be profitable. I am a member
at FAPWinner and I follow Charles' recommendations on the
trend direction. The performance with these
system appears to comes down to your ability to know when to
turn them on and off. So far Charles has done a good
job of calling the end of the trend.
Visit the
official ForexAutoPilot site


ForexRobotShop Membership
I will be adding more reviews of
other Forex Systems in the future. Sign up to the
ForexRobotShop Membership to be notified by
email.
Privacy Policy
Back to
Top
Note:
Forex trading can involve a risk of substantial loss,
and is not suitable for everyone. Be sure to only trade
with money you can afford to lose.
All
information contained in this website is for educational
purposes only and should not be considered financial
advice. By using this site, you agree to
our terms of use and
disclaimer .
|